
The Parable of the Salton Sea
November 15, 2026
In 1905 canals meant to divert the Colorado River were breached and instead of drawing off the water meant for the Gulf the entire Colorado River flowed into an ancient salt flat for two years. This misdirection created the Salton Sea of Southern California.
The Salton Sea was an accident created first by diverted farm water, then it grew with a hurricane, and became immense with unusual amounts of rainfall. In no time it became a boater's paradise. And birds. Birds and thus birders flocked to the newly formed inland sea. Surrounded by cacti and palm bedecked mountains to the east and west and Palm Springs in the north, the Salton Sea boomed in the 1950s as a resort destination, the "new Riviera".
Fishing was good too. Migration of thousands of pelicans, cranes, and ibis meant you could drive to the desert in the winter, swim and relax by day with the birds and then enjoy the unbounded night sky of the Sonoran desert.
My grandfather, Paul Tritle, and his third wife, Lucy, moved there in between the boom and the bust. They built a home on one of dredged canals and fished for corvina. As a boy I took a bus from San Diego to El Centro to stay with them in the summer. They fetched me at the bus station with my small suitcase, took me to their cinderblock home on the sea.
During those summer days the heat would rise to 120 and then plummet at night. I will never forget shivering in the chill after the sun set playing dominoes with my grandfather with stars so close you could almost touch them.
Paul and Lucy left before the impact of the Hoover Dam and better irrigation techniques choked the Salton Sea. Today it is slowly dying, shrinking; it is known more for its smell than anything else. No longer a paradise, more a purgatory.
One summer long before the the smell of sulfur overwhelmed, during a visit my grandfather took me to an abandoned mansion across the sea. It looked like the Guggenheim Museum in Manhattan, spaceship on the water; he drove his boat right into the center of the house. There were ramps and docks inside the massive concrete resort. You could almost hear the grandeur of a few decades, the dinner parties and celebrities. You could sense this was once a remarkable place. Mostly though you could not miss the demise. The portent was clear, the boom was over, the bust had come.
From 1942 till 1977 The Reverend Adolph Behrenberg was the pastor here in Metuchen. When he came, this congregation was a healthy farming community slowly becoming a suburb of Manhattan. What began as a prayer house of Woodbridge Presbyterian in 1717, and grew to the 1940s to 300 members, was a modest church. Its claim to fame before Behrenberg was their longest serving pastor, Dr. Mason, who was a dear friend of Thomas Edison. Edison often debuted his latest inventions in this sanctuary. The phonograph was introduced to the world here. At its heart, though, this was a church in a community.
By 1977 things had changed. The New York Times ran a story about the passing of Dr. Behrenberg, not an obit, article. The remarkable rise of the church was noted. Once a farming church of 300 was now a suburban congregation of 2300. Behrenberg was credited with the growth and also remembered as a world traveler, circumnavigating the globe many times. What was modest became massive.
When I came to Metuchen in 2018, I was told much of this, but I was also told a disturbing rumor, a piece of gossip about Behrenberg's declining years. Without question he suffered the insinuations slung at a closeted gay man, but this was more than insult. This bothered me greatly. So in 2022 I began research on a project allowing me to discover the rumor was not true. Certainly a man with flaws, but no more than you or me.
How I discovered this was a strange coincidence. I wanted to hear his voice, read something he wrote. I discovered the special collections at Princeton Seminary did indeed have something from his hand. When I enquired as to the holding, the archivist told me they had 37 boxes of material. 37 boxes of sermons, travelogues and diaries. The first year I spent with the boxes I read only the sermons.
Behrenberg was an orator, bombastic, inflammatory. His sermons were the Barthian balance of the bible in one hand and the New York Times in other. Often while reading one of his diatribes I would pause and think, "well, I'd be fired." During the height of McCarthy he wrote, "I too am a communist as is any Christian." Perhaps the most memorable was his declaration about the city of Newark in 1968 as it was engulfed in riots. He said, "they have no good schools, no good jobs, the housing is deplorable, why would they not burn the city to the ground?"
After a year of resisting the remainder of the boxes, I gave in, opened those holding his diaries. In the collected papers were thirty-five years of daily diaries. This was an exceptionally disciplined man. He wrote one-page everyday top-to-bottom. What I found in the diaries was a fascinating contrast. In the pulpit he was power, full of bravado; in the manse at the end of the day he was fearful, worried, often debilitated by a future he dreaded.
Two things of note. Having the diaries allowed dry session meeting minutes to come alive. Motion-second-pass became heated debate, wrangling, tears of rage and joy. All I needed to do was read the diary entry after a session meeting to get the real story, or at least a more interesting version than "it was discussed."
The second moment of note came in the late sixties. Behrenberg lamented the impending decline of our denomination. He lamented in his diaries, the boom was over, the bust was about to begin. There was a shift, change, a mood and he could see it. As clearly as we are seeing the evidence of Fall, so too he could see the markers of denominational decline. I remember starring at his diary entry stunned. He was at the zenith, and he was not lost in unbridled confidence, he was certain of demise.
The reading from Luke, the parable of the fig tree or the parable of any tree in leaf, is a culmination, a last word as it were about time and the end/purpose of history, the recurring cycles of era and eon. Like Aristotle and Nietzsche, Jesus is suggesting time is a cyclical creation of rising and falling, success and failure, beginning, ending, and new beginning.
The lesson of the fig tree comes after Jesus has warned of the fall of Jerusalem, the needless pursuit of rumors, the likelihood of false prophets, the certainty of generational, even familial betrayal. The fig tree lesson teaches the inevitability of change, change as a true constant, with only one exception, his word. Even heaven will change, neither stone nor pearly gate will escape evolution.
The little apocalypse of Jesus is nearly done with the call to see all as impermanent. Luke though inserts a slight change from Matthew and Mark. A change tying the apocalypse to the life of ministry, the teachings of Galilee and now Judea. He claims the kingdom of God has come near. The kingdom of God will come near even in the transiency of life’s ebb and flow. This generation will not end until the kingdom of God is near at hand.
I have a lovely memory born of spending a year with the Princeton Seminary professor James Loder. In 1993-94 I spent a year trying to see, appreciate, and understand the structure of irony. In the course of the year I met with Dr. Loder many times, spent hours in seminars he taught. The lovely memory, something evoked each time I read the words of Jesus claiming the proximity of the kingdom of God, the lovely memory is how Dr. Loder would stop a discussion, a conversation by taking a deep breath in and allow his breath to leave him before he would declare, “the teacher is here.”
He made this claim, “the teacher is here” with a sense of awe and respect, delight and wonder. Somebody said something good, somebody has the Holy Spirit, like the spiritual, somebody touched me, must be hand of the Lord. It was as if the angels disturbing the water at the pool of Siloam were passing by again, as if the burning bush were illumined once more begging you linger, take off your shoes. Whenever I read “the kingdom of God is near” I am taken back to his voice and deep breath, the presence of God is here, with us, how wonderful.
In the synoptics Jesus speaks of the kingdom of God more than 60 times. I am always surprised by how little we speak of it, how infrequently our attention lingers with this claim. Sometimes I feel it is the lede we have buried, the focus we have lost. The kingdom of God is here and now, at hand, in you. What in the world does this mean? How are you the one who carries the kingdom of God; how are we the proclamation of the kingdom of God? To me this is the great question of the church. Where can this kingdom can be found today?
Sometimes when I consider my life in ministry, sometimes I feel like I am overseeing the erosion of the Salton Sea. A huge deluge of people, an influx of thousands with sanctuaries built to contain this multitude and education wings meant to corral their offspring. When I consider the corporate structure meant to navigate the growth, the org charts and compliance, the hierarchies and denominational big tents meant to embody regional franchises, when I consider this, I am mindful of Dr. Behrenberg’s premonition, the zenith was reached.
In the coming weeks this congregation will know the results of a very timely capital campaign. Funds nearing 2 million dollars are being raised to renovate the sanctuary not renovated since the 1950s, when Dr. Behrenberg designed this pulpit, chancel. Like all buildings this new iteration will have an age. If done well there will be three, four more generations living in worship here. Seventy, eighty years from now someone will say, “I love this space, don’t get me wrong, but it’s time for a change.”
With these changes this congregation will have redone, remodeled, reimagined everything born of the dramatic growth of the 1950s. With this last step the entire campus will be renovated. This is exciting, good. I look forward to a pulpit closer to the ground and a chancel open to all. Yet what I hope most is not about space, but the possibility of the corporate church fading and a new life emerging. So much energy, time, and talent has been spent trying to maintain the unique moment of the past, the explosion of growth after WWII, so much energy trying to maintain the corporate church, and often so little time asking, how has the kingdom of God come near, here and now?
How can we find this kingdom?
We have always found it in prayer and song, fellowship and study. Yet so often now the Holy Spirit comes in food pantries and transitional housing, acts of compassion and service to the neighbor you no longer ignore. I am so hopeful for the future of our denomination when I see and hear congregations finding “the teacher is here.”
After changes upon changes we are more or less the same. The prayer house built in 1717, its still here. The boldness to trust humility, to give our life to keep it, still here. The Salton Sea will return to a salt flat, and the corporate church will be a community once again. Amen.
